Religion and the 2012 Elections

Theoretical physicist and cosmologist Lawrence M. Krauss has written a concise but poignant essay, “Why are Religious Beliefs Off Limits?,” about whether religion and the religious beliefs of the candidates should be addressed or not in the public discourse during the elections this year. It wasn’t that long ago when religious beliefs were considered private affairs. Candidate John F. Kennedy’s answer to those who worried about his Catholicism affirmed the privacy of his religious beliefs and how Church teaching would have no impact on his public policy. But the rhetoric has changed dramatically. It is significant that Rick Santorum said Kennedy’s view “made him want to throw up.” Howard Fineman has pointed out why he thinks the GOP is America’s first religious party.

Krauss’ full essay is a must-read. He asks and concludes, in an election cycle when religion is being worn on one’s sleeve, …

… should we not be able to question whether the beliefs of the religion publicly espoused by a candidate may reflect on candidate’s judgment and their ability to distinguish sense from nonsense? […]
When a person’s religious beliefs cause him to deny the evidence of science, or for whom public policy morphs into a battle with the devil, shouldn’t that be a subject for discussion and debate? […]
why should we not focus on the actual content of the publicly espoused beliefs held by politicians? […]
It thus seems fair game to openly and directly ask Mr. Romney and Mr. Santorum to outline the specifics of their beliefs about the sacred as well as the profane, in order to more fully probe the character and intellect anyone who proposes to lead this nation. To do any less is to be negligent in our duties as citizens.

To the extent that any other candidate, including President Obama also chooses to wear his religion on his sleeve (and regrettably there are no female candidates that would require my use of a gender-neutral pronoun) this should also apply. Santorum’s religio-centric views are generating a lot of discussion, but so far Romney’s Mormonism has been free of scrutiny. Personally, I would like to know more about beliefs around the temple underwear (especially the almost magical-sounding official view that “when properly worn…provides protection against temptation and evil,”) but as a matter of public policy I am more interested in his personal views and participation in rituals of baptism of the dead, especially Jewish victims of the Holocaust, which Romney has apparently refused to discuss. Yes, I think that and some other things matter.

Read Dr. Krauss’ full essay here. His full bio is here, an impressive read itself but which I have included also for those tempted to go ad hominem simply because the essay appears in the Huffington Post.

Save this on Delicious

2 thoughts on “Religion and the 2012 Elections

  1. I thought it was hilarious when Stephen Colbert said that Jews should start baptizing dead Mormons to make them Jewish. I can’t recall his exact wording and I don’t like to misquote anyone, but you get the general idea. What I can’t figure out is how the church selects their “victims” for this strange ritual. Could they be anti-semitic or am I reading too much into it?

  2. I agree with these sentiments. It just shows how entitled religion is in our society. I’m hoping the current culture of the religious right will kill that off somewhat. I am afraid of the nut-jobs but hopeful that there are enough educated, thoughtful, independent people out there that won’t vote them in to office. The nice thing about them getting REALLY crazy is that they will scare many off. BTW – you may have heard, but next week’s Doonesbury is supposed to be a doozy. At the risk of pissing off a lot of people, I think I will be posting to my facebook page.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s